Women Don't Really Want Lower-Paying Jobs. So Why Do We Pick the Majors That Place Us There?

Why do women select colleges that have lower earning potential?  According to a new survey, we do.

Newswise.com reports that even when both male and female college students say they want to pursue a major with the best earnings prospects, "the majors men choose are higher paying than the majors women choose."

In a new study, sociologist Natasha Quadlin of The Ohio State University found that “the logics of major choice” may lead women to select different majors from men, despite having similar preferences. 

“Even when women place great emphasis on earnings, other preferences may ultimately win out for them,” said Quadlin, assistant professor of sociology at Ohio State. 

One possible competing preference: finding a field that’s a good fit. 

So is that why we're teachers and nurses?  But wait.  We're also doctors and lawyers and fire chiefs.

Quadlin surveyed 2,720 students from three higher education institutions that had programs intended to attract and retain STEM majors. 

"Each student was asked during their first term to rate on a scale of 1 to 5 how important four considerations were to them when selecting a major: money earned, career options, engaging classes, and helping others," newswise notes. 

Students later reported which major they selected.  Quadlin also used federal data to examine the earnings associated with each major. 

“The pattern was clear: The majors men choose are associated with significantly higher earning than the majors women choose – regardless of men’s and women’s major preferences,” she says at the web site. 

So when men and women both prioritize economic returns in their preferences for a major, men still choose majors that pay more. 

But even when men and women prioritized other preferences for their major – such as helping people – men still chose higher-paying majors, the findings showed. 

For example, men who said they wanted a major where they could help people were more likely than women to choose biology, a pre-med major, because they thought doctors helped people. But women who wanted to help people were more likely than men to choose nursing. 

“Nursing is a relatively high-paying job, but it generally doesn’t pay as much as doctors can earn,” Quadlin says. 

The big question:  Why do women choose different majors from men, even when they share the same preferences?

One reason may have to do with what jobs men and women think are realistic for them, explains Quadlin. 

“There’s research that suggests men and women have very different ideas about what types of careers and fields are open and available to them,” she says. Simple.  “Some STEM careers that pay the most may not be as receptive to women as they are to men, so women adjust what majors they select.” 

The result is that women who are motivated to make a lot of money choose majors that are relatively high-paying, but also more open and available to women, Quadlin says. 

The results of the study suggest that attracting women to STEM may not be as easy as changing their preferences, because changing their preferences may not lead them to actually choose the STEM careers they’re encouraged to select. 

“You may not be able to attract women to high-paying STEM careers just by telling them it is a way to make a lot of money or a way to help other people,” Quadlin said. “Instead, we may have more to do with changing the culture around STEM so that women feel the field is more open and receptive to them.”